I want to:
See replies by others
Post to this group
See my posts
Look at my profile
Change my profile
See my membership status
Quick search

Books by members - memories ...
Events RSS feed
New members RSS feed
Attila Meszaros
Attila Meszaros 
 
 
Ehab Bassilli
Ehab Bassilli 
 
 
Dmitri Vinnikov
Dmitri Vinnikov 
Tallinn University of Technology 
 
Post
Blog / post
Categories » academici Reviews » Business, Economics, Maths Reviews » Business and Economics Reviews
Review: Carsten Wilhelm, Familie und Beruf
Wege zur Vereinbarkeit
Saturday, February 09, 2008 - Family and career - how to combine them?

The book:
Carsten Wilhelm, Familie und Beruf. Wege zur Vereinbarkeit, Saarbruecken: VDM Verlag Dr. Mueller 2007, ISBN 978-3-8364-1160-0, 118p


Over the past years, even managers in very demanding positions, are looking not only for work-life integration into their career management, but with a growing value of family ethics against a purely consumer oriented single life mentality, they are searching how to preserve or even enhance time for family, partner and children while at the same time being able to perform in business. Books, such as Brad Harrington/T. Hall (Boston University) on "Career Management & Work-Life Integration. Using Self-Assessment to Navigate Contemporary Careers" (Sage Publications 2007) are coming to the market, while authors such as Jody Heymann (Forgotten Families: Ending the Growing Crisis Confronting Children and Working Parents in the Global Economy, OUP 2006) are warning against a decline of family structures in a highly competitive globalised career market. Hence, it is a good addition to have a book now that looks at the (rather conservative) German background but also broadens out to other European countries (Sweden, Finland, France, The Netherlands - one would have liked to see also newly entered European countries, of course with their specific challenges).
The book has 7 main chapters, covering demographic and other influences (change in spare time habits, globalisation ...), family-friendly initiatives in various companies (flexible working hours, job-sharing ...), work organisation, child care at work, HR and work-family balance. Three more or less independent chapters cover work-family balance in the other, named European countries, the effects of work-family balance on a company's p&o and a chapter on PEUGEOT Deutschland GmbH as a case in point.
The author can clearly demonstrate that not only in Germany there is a direct relation between career - work-family policy and the number of children being born. The more both parents embark on a career path in an environment where work-family and work-life balance is underdeveloped fewer children are born. As a result, in Germany, we have got a drastic decline in procreation which in the meantime (2004) has reached 1,36 children per woman, which is far below 2,1, the necessary average for keeping up a society (13f.). This contrasts with the experience in countries like Sweden, Finland or The Netherlands. Studies have shown that the opposite statement can be made: "The more women participate in the workforce, the more children are born within that country. Whereas in countries with only slightly more than 50% women at the age between 15 and 54 working, provide the lowest birthrate, fertility is growing with a growing participation of women in the workforce." (Kroehner/van Olst/Klingholz, 2005; 58). Being a rather conservative country when it comes to role models, even in Germany, the role of fathers is changing and more and more men are opting for family time when it comes to crucial decisions whether to opt for a career development or to spend more time with wife and children (22).
Hence, societies and companies have no other options than to engage into more work-life balance strategies to gain and retain its skilled workforce (various options: 30-45), although one of the biggest needs seems to be the lacking child care places for children under 3 (40). In addition, the author can indicate that investments into a work-family policy does not only sustain a society, but also pays out for a company (80). Peugeot Deutschland serves as an example with (France driven) developed family policy and, as a result, for example falling illness related off days of the workforce (83).
Despite its character of a study that derived from a "Diplomarbeit", a thesis which was originally written for Prof. Dr. Uwe Leprich (HTW des Saarlandes), obviously without too many changes, the book is a welcomed contribution to a topic that will be discussed further over the next years. With its comparative character that focusses not only on Germany, but looks at other countries, particularly France (using a Saarland based French/German company), it highlights the specific need for Germany to catch up with policy developments in other European countries. For this purpose, it calls for further, in-depth and forward looking studies, to provide more hard facts on long-term effects for a European and national economy, but also for companies. More specifically one is looking for further studies that highlight the specific perspectives of fathers or mothers as regards work-life balance, and the existing industry around it (coaching, consulting ...). 

upgrade today!
upgrade today!
Sort by old replies first
Replies to post
2/9/2008 1:04 PM - Anne Carpentier

Dear Robert,

indeed, there are a few, although there could be more. Maybe the one that deals most accurately with your question, covering the States and Germany is a PhD dissertation that was written in 1996 at Duke University by Patricia A. McManus and subsequently published by her as Welfare capitalism, the family and small business : self-employment in the United States and Germany, Ann Arbor 1998 ($ 51.50).
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation published the following study in the UK: Self-employment and family-friendly working, York : Joseph Rowntree Foundation, 2003, ISSN: 0958-3084
Or take the studies by Wellington, Alison J., Self-employment: the new solution for balancing family and career?: Labour economics 13 (2006) 357-386

There is an interesting article dealing with the same topic with a gender focus: by J Boden Jr, REMEMBRANCE AND APPRECIATION FEATURE - Flexible Working Hours, Family Responsibilities, and Female Self-Employment: The American journal of economics and sociology. 58/1 (1999) 71ff.
Similarly, Richard J. Boden, Flexible working hours, family responsibilities, and female self-employment : gender differences in self-employment selection: The American journal of economics and sociology 58 (1999) 71-83

In 1999 the US National Bureau of Economic Research published a small booklet in his Working paper series nr. 7344 that focusses on the ethnic impact on the issue. The book is by Michael Hout and Harvey S. Rosen, Self-employment, family background, and race, Cambridge, Mass. : NBER 1999. A similar focus has the following article: Immigrant Self-Employment: The Family as Social Capital and the Value of Human Capital
by Jimy M Sanders; Victor Nee: American sociological review 61/2 (1996) 231.

I hope that helps as a start and shows that there is scope for more studies in this upcoming area.

Yours Anne
 
1/15/2008 9:53 AM - Robert Kircher-Reineke

 I appreciated the appraisal regarding this up to date issue. However, I am wondering if there is literature or, even better, research outcomes available that reflect upon the increasing number of parents, be it fathers or mothers, who decide upon their lifes to be independant from any companys´ work schedule.  Drawing back to the growing number of consultancy/coaching etc. offers (at least in Germany), there must be a growing number of those who start their own businesses and, in effect, not having less to do but a more flexible work schedule.


Markus Vinzent
University of Birmingham (from 09/10: King's College London)
Other posts by author
No posts available
Last read by
Umar Ruhi
Chris Wojtulewicz
K. Kung
Sylvia Pullig
Kean Kok Ng
Keywords
Management/Operations  Publishing